Vikings may not be sold on J.J. McCarthy

by | Oct 4, 2025 | Local | 0 comments

admin

admin


It has to be incredibly frustrating for Vikings owners Zygi and Mark Wilf, who spent more money ($345 million) than any of the other 31 NFL teams for a 2-2 start this season. The Vikings have been devastated by injuries to high-paid players.

Meanwhile, quarterback J.J. McCarthy, also injured, had been underwhelming except for one quarter before his high right ankle sprain. The Vikings won’t say it publicly, but at this juncture it’s a decent bet they wish they had kept Sam Darnold, who has led the Seattle Seahawks to a 3-1 start. Or signed Daniel Jones, whose Indianapolis Colts are 3-1 with him under center.

The Vikings could have franchise-tagged Darnold, 28, for one year at $37 million while providing McCarthy, 22, another year to develop. Also, insiders say Aaron Rodgers, 41, who beat the Vikings in Ireland last Sunday, nearly begged the Vikings to sign him before signing with the Pittsburgh Steelers, who are 3-1.

— Entering this season, the Vikings’ plan was to build a veteran roster to support McCarthy, who is expected to return as starter against the Philadelphia Eagles in Minneapolis after next week’s bye. By then, the Vikings should have an idea whether they can go forward with McCarthy or need to reevaluate their quarterback future.

For McCarthy, the rest of this season will be an audition. If he shows promise, the Vikings will continue to build around him. If he plays poorly, the Vikings may have to rethink their decision drafting him No. 10 overall two years ago and, depending on their 2026 draft position, maybe even take another quarterback in the first round.

Charley Walters (Pioneer Press: Scott Takushi)
Charley Walters (Pioneer Press: Scott Takushi)

The way it looks now, the Vikings’ first-round draft pick next year will be in the Nos. 10-12 range. Another QB route for the Vikings would be to sign a veteran more skilled than Carson Wentz with the understanding that McCarthy will need to compete for the starting job in 2026. Theoretically, believe it or not, that guy could be Kirk Cousins, 37, the backup in Atlanta. The Falcons do not have their first- or fifth-round picks in next year’s draft. The trade deadline is Nov. 4.

— Another potential free agent QB having a good season (4-1) is Mac Jones, who just turned 27, with the San Francisco 49ers.

In 2023, with the No. 4 pick in the draft, the Colts took Anthony Richardson. After two years of injuries and inconsistency, the Colts decided they would go into this season (year three) not merely handing the job to Richardson, but with open competition with Jones for the starting job, which Jones has won.

— The Vikings are fortunate they don’t have to face new Green Bay edge rusher Micah Parsons until Nov. 23. Through four games, Parsons leads the NFL in pass-rushing grade, per Pro Football Focus.

— It should be a big payday from the Chicago Cubs this winter for Simley High grad Michael Busch, who finished the regular season with 34 home runs and 90 runs batted in while hitting .263. Busch, 27, who led off the NL Division Series with a home run Saturday and also homered last week against San Diego, played for $780,500 this season. He isn’t eligible for full arbitration until 2027, but an anticipated Cubs offer could be in the $70 million, five-year range.

— Totino-Grace grad Joe Alt, the Los Angeles Chargers’ top draft pick (No. 5 overall) last spring now out with a badly sprained ankle, bought Five Guys hamburgers for fellow offensive linemen after a practice last week.

— Pulling for Louie Mitteco, the hall of fame former Totino Grace and St. Charles Borromeo basketball coaching legend from Minneapolis facing health challenges.

— The Miami Heat have signed former Park Center star Dain Dainja and former Rochester Mayo star Gabe Madsen, who passed Roseville’s Nick Jacobson to become Utah’s career three-point leader.

— The Utah Jazz have signed ex-Eastview star Steven Crowl, who played at Wisconsin.



Source link

0 Comments

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Pin It on Pinterest